1958-1959  Cecil J. Barber; J.A. Barber & Sons; Youngstown
1959-1960  John M. Metzger; Jobbers Supply; Columbus
1960-1961  Bill Hedges; Hedges Auto Parts; Portsmouth
1961-1962  Charles J. Boland; Boland Ignition Co.; Cleveland
1962-1963  Chet H. Newman; Lewis Motor Mart; Dayton
1963-1964  Tom C. Igo Jr.; Miles Auto Stores; Cleveland  
1964-1965  Nick Buchman; Dillon Auto Parts; Fostoria
1965-1966  Robert E. Thomas; Sanborn Motor Equipment; Painesville
1966-1967  Tom M. Toolin; Automotive Parts; Columbus
1967-1968  E.C. (Bud) Snider; Johnston Auto Supply; Springfield
1968-1969  Richard A. Franz; F & N Motor Co.; Cincinnati
1969-1970  Leonard G. Duncan; Defiance Auto Supply; Defiance
1970-1971  Melvin L. Erb; Reliable Auto Parts; Dover
1971-1972  Robert Goldman; Goldman Car Pts., Bowling Green
1972-1974  Robert C. Gehring; Wayne Auto Parts; Wooster
1974-1975  Ed L. Asher; The Asher Bros. Co.; Sandusky
1975-1977  Charles E. Lawrence; B & L Auto Supply; Newark
1977-1978  Tom L. Krupp; Buckeye Auto Parts; Fostoria
1978-1980  Joe H. Wesel; Marietta Ignition; Marietta
1980-1981  Jack N. Thayer; Steego Parts Corp.; Columbus
1981-1982  Ken C. Kopfmann; Toledo Auto Electric; Toledo
1982-1983  Leonard E. Morse; Medina Auto Parts; Medina
1983-1984  Rich A. Campbell; Toledo Auto & Truck Supply; Toledo
1984-1985  Dan Dunson; Dunson Supply Co.; Sidney
1985-1986  Charles W. (Bill) Wesel; Marietta Ignition; Marietta
1986-1987  Ralph Coon; Semco Auto Parts; Copley
1987-1988  Ed Occhionero; Crest Motor Parts; Lyndhurst
1988-1989  Paul Brecht, Jr.; Paul's Automotive; Toledo
1989-1990  John Detrick; Springfield Tire & Battery; Springfield
1990-1991  Tom Eden; Lant Auto Parts; Ashtabula
1991-1992  Ken Washington; Ken Washington Auto Parts; Johnstown
1992-1993  Dan Herrold; Met's Auto Supply; Mansfield
1993-1994  Jim Pullins; Springfield Auto Supply, Inc.; Springfield
1994-1995  Jim Roe; Midwest Fender; Columbus
1995-1996  Jeff Erb; Reliable Auto Parts; Dover
1996-1997  John Lawrence; CarQuest of Newark; Newark
1997-1998  Jim Amstutz; Central Ohio Power Tool; Columbus
1998-1999  H.M. "Chip" Childress; UCI Midwest; Dayton
1999-2000  Lynn Sinclair: Orlo Auto Parts; Orrville
2000-2001  John Hill; Willard C. Starcher, Inc.; Spencer, WV
2002-2003  Lee Menke; R&R Engine & Machine; Akron, OH
2004-2005  Dan Mader; Mader Motor Mart; Troy, OH
2006-2007  Keith Blankenship; AutoValue of Matewan; Matewan, WV
2008-2009  Robert Washington, Washington Auto Parts & Paint ,Johnstown, OH
2010-2011  Jim Smith; JSC Group, LLC; Johnstown, OH                   
2012-2013  Mark Lewis; Mansfield Auto Parts; Mansfield, OH                                                                  

2014-2015  Craig Speckman; Speckman Automotive, Inc. ; St. Mary's, OH